March 02, 2004

Police Force versus Army


The Haitian Support Group is against the formation of an army for Haiti, seeing such a development as the fastest road back to the history of dictatorship.

Some would argue, maybe too abstractly, that a democratic, universal-service military is the greatest insurance policy against such dictatorship.

So far, the argument for a police force -- not an army -- has the saints on its sides. Who, however, is reading history correctly?

Click on this LINK to open an important position statement from a leader of the Haitian Support Group.

Human Camera -- Port-au-Prince

Yesterday, with Aristide fleeing in a U.S. jet while Colin Powell is on the phone to desparately find a country somewhere on the globe that will offer the reverend safe haven, I figured the big news would be covered in The Wall Street Journal. (The WSJ is the only paper from New York, London or Paris that arrives in Montréal before noon of the day it appears.)

They ran the story on Page 3 with only a tiny summary on the front page, so I bought Canada's Globe & Mail instead and got the latest news.

But, as we saw in Afghanistan and Iraq, when you read The Independent or the Guardian (both English) you are offered a more humanly objective view compared to any of the major American papers treating a situation even remotely touching on U.S. strategic and economic interests.

Click to see how The Independent offers cinema verte on one day in the Caribbean capitol without trite expressions about the politics.

Click this LINK, and a local file will appear on your screen.


March 01, 2004

HAITI: SOME KNOWNS, MANY UNKNOWNS

The only thing clear is that Supreme Court Chief Justice Boniface Alexandre was sworn in as president within six hours after Aristide's departure.Beyond that, given Haiti's chronic unpredictability, anything is possible.

For the local copy of an article today in the Miami Herald, click on this LINK.

February 27, 2004

U.S. Civil Liberties on PBS

Regarding the upcoming March 5, 2004 "Now with Bill Moyers" show and an interview with Brian Terrell of Iowa's Catholic Peace Ministry:

Here are some details and background worth mentioning --

I consider it high time the public broadcast media provide coverage of what happened last November 2003 when local peace activists demonstrated at Camp Dodge and especially analysis of what ensued. The four grand jury summonses issued three months later were clearly designed to chill peace activism in Des Moines and to scare Drake administrators. But despite a handful of articles in the leading East Coast print media and the Des Moines Register, the story has not received the type of international coverage it deserves.

You might argue that this low profile is because the whole legal matter was dropped. But I sense that, in the event a grand jury actually handed down indictments, the inevitable long wait before matters came to court for a trial would cause the media to "chill out" and unplug the spotlights. I am not reading tea leaves here, but taking a sounding on just how shallow the waters of progressivism in America are currently running on the broad scale of things. In the late 60s five of us were indicted in Iowa City for conspiracy by a grand jury. But within a month, despite the fact that convictions could lead to 3-year jail terms, attention by the media evaporated. Nobody wanted to be reminded. All of us were in jail a few days (without being charged) and some of us sat in jail an additional two weeks when a judge refused to accept bail for earlier convictions from previous demonstrations. By that short time-span the matter had completely fizzled although it hung over our heads like a sword for three or more years and we had all simply gone on about our normal-for-the-sixties lives.

Here are some specific details about the "Now with Bill Moyers" show, now that the interview has been rescheduled: Moyers will run at 9 pm Central Standard Time (CST) on Channel 11 locally, but that does not mean it runs at the same time or same date in all the cities where the Iowa Peace Network's emails will be landing in someone's in-box.

In Montreal it can be seen on Mountain Lake PBS, Channel 57, Burlington, VT at 10:00 pm Eastern Time. KCTS Seattle, WA will run the show March 5 at 9 pm, but in Miami, FLA the show runs on WPBT Channel 2 March 7 at 10:30 am Eastern Time.

The best way to get a sneak preview of what is coming up with Moyers is to sign up for the program's newsletter by email at http://www.pbs.org/now/newsletter.html . You might want to keep up with your individual PBS station's programming announcements on their own website as well.

Mar 5, 2004, 10:00 pm, by the way, is also the time 'Now with Bill Moyers' will air at KQED in San Francisco. KQED, by the way, has one of the most interesting public broadcasting website's (http://www.kqed.org/ is worth browsing, much meatier than Iowa Public Television's effort at http://www.iptv.org/ where you find no local coverage of the grand jury intimidation). KQED at least covers civil liberties issues regularly. But none of the PBS sites I have seen recently are adequately covering these February 2004 attacks on peace activism in Iowa.

I end this message with a postscript pasted below showing that the show Moyers hosts has been exemplary in covering the civil liberties side to the assaults currently being carried out globally by the U.S. against people who were better off before they were 'liberated.'

-- RJP

Postscript

One public broadcasting bright spot for clarity recently was when interviewer JuJu Chang met with guest John Cole (a professor of law at Georgetown University who has been called one of America’s greatest voices for civil liberties) on Moyers' show. Professor Cole stated the following:

"There have actually been 5,000… over 5,000 people detained since September 11th in anti-terrorism initiatives undertaken by the Justice Department. And of those 5,000, only three were charged with any crime related to terrorism.

"And of those three, only one was convicted, and not actually of engaging in terrorist activity or even planning terrorist activity, but of conspiring to support some unidentified terrorist acts in the unidentified future. So you got 5,000 people locked up on pretexts who had nothing to do with terrorism.

What it does do is alienate the very community that has been targeted."


-- See the transcript at http://www.pbs.org/now/politics/civilliberties.html)

Haiti: The Altar of Saviour Politics

The trouble didn't start, as is often claimed, with slightly fiddled elections in 2000 that Aristide would have won anyway. It started before that, with unpunished killings of opponents, the takeover of the police by his henchmen, the looting of public funds — turning thousands of idealistic supporters against him and giving a green light to the lawless youths now manning the barricades in the capital, Port-au-Prince, as the U.S. government struggles for a solution tailored to its own election year rather than the needs of Haiti.

. ++ ++ ++ .

Michèle Montas, journaliste vedette haïtienne --

Il est vrai qu'avec une trentaine de coups d'Etat en deux cents ans d'indépendance, avec les Duvalier, le régime militaire du général Cedras, et maintenant Jean-Bertrand Aristide, mon pays a eu son lot de violences politiques. Mais de là à parler de fatalité...

L'histoire d'Haïti, c'est aussi et surtout l'histoire du
long combat d'un peuple pour sa place au soleil.
Un combat exemplaire qui a commencé, je vous
le rappelle, face aux troupes de Napoléon.

Qu'un groupe d'esclaves ait pu défaire une armée
si prestigieuse, n'était-ce pas refuser cette
fatalité dont vous parlez ?

- - Vendredi 20 février, Figaro Magazine

Click on the LINK